The right journal, the right article type, the right stage.
How to Check a Journal’s Author Guidelines: Match the Article and Submission Stage
Build your checklist from the target journal’s current instructions and the stage you are submitting. PLOS ONE specifies a revision package; Wiley’s Free Format program describes flexibility for participating journals. Neither example is a universal rule for every publisher. [2] [3]
AcademicFix Editorial Team · Sources reviewed:

Find the decision hidden behind “check the guidelines”
Record what the rule applies to before changing a document.
Match title, article type and stage
A general publisher page is a starting point for the selected journal.
Build the instruction record02 / Actual policyWhat is flexible?Separate format choice from required content
Compare documented examples without treating them as one publisher-wide rule.
Read the scoped comparison03 / File evidenceWhat is missing?Check the requested artifacts
A clean manuscript alone is not the full PLOS ONE revision example.
Try the hypothetical package checkFor authors preparing an initial submission or a revision. This is a method for recording instructions and checking a package, not a full policy summary of either publisher. It does not replace the journal’s current pages, decision letter or study-specific requirements.
On this page
1. Record which instructions govern this submission
Editorial workflow: save the journal title, article type, initial/revision stage, guideline URL, section heading and access date. Record a decision-letter instruction separately from a general webpage. Then attach the evidence you checked: file, page, statement or portal field.
Read the Aims & Scope and accepted article types before polishing layout. For each length limit, record what counts: abstract, main text, references, captions or supplementary material. Do not copy a limit from another journal or infer that a word processor’s total uses the same counting rule.
2. Compare real policies with their scope attached
| Source and scope | Documented requirement or flexibility | Decision for your checklist |
|---|---|---|
| PLOS ONE submission guide | DOC, DOCX or RTF manuscript files; LaTeX manuscripts as PDFs. Individual figure files are requested. [1] | Check the workflow and upload roles for the actual files you prepared. |
| PLOS ONE revision guide | A response, a marked-up manuscript and a clean manuscript are requested. Figures and supporting files transfer unless replaced. [2] | Track the three requested artifacts separately and inspect inherited files. |
| Wiley journals offering Free Format | A preferred consistent format is permitted. Required sections and applicable ethics/conflict statements still belong in the manuscript. [3] | Confirm that the selected journal offers the program and check its own instructions. |
PLOS ONE also treats manuscript length and abstract length separately. A statement about unrestricted manuscript length should not be read as permission to ignore the abstract instructions. [1] The lesson is to preserve the scope of each rule, not to build a universal PLOS–Wiley template.
3. A hypothetical revision package: the clean file is only one artifact
Hypothetical teaching scenario; no real manuscript or submission. An author preparing a PLOS ONE revision has a clean manuscript file but has not yet prepared the reviewer response or the marked-up version. Apply the revision guide’s requested artifact list to that inventory. [2]
| Requested artifact | Hypothetical inventory | Next action |
|---|---|---|
| Response to reviewers | Missing | Prepare the point-by-point response. |
| Marked-up manuscript | Missing | Provide the changes in the journal’s requested form. |
| Clean manuscript | Listed as available | Open and inspect the actual file; availability is not approval. |
The difference between the required artifact names and this hypothetical inventory returns the response and marked-up manuscript as missing. This checks names only. It does not validate a manuscript, prove that comments were answered, inspect figures or certify submission readiness.
Do not automatically delete files carried over from an earlier round. PLOS ONE describes how original figures and supporting files transfer; compare the inherited versions with your revised text before replacing them. [2]
4. Use a traceable record instead of unexplained checkmarks
The following fields are our editorial recommendation. Complete them for the target journal rather than copying the example policies.
- Scope and type: journal page, selected article type and the reason the work fits.
- Length and structure: limit, counting inclusions, required headings and evidence from the actual document.
- Files and references: accepted format, figure/table instructions, chosen citation style, matched reference records and relevant DOI checks.
- Statements: applicable contributions, funding, conflicts, data/code and other requested disclosures; never invent approval or permissions.
- Review model: whether identity concealment applies, where identifying information belongs, and any unresolved instruction.
- Stage and outcome: initial/revision, artifact or portal role, checked date, person responsible and unresolved work.
Free Format is a formatting permission in the cited program. Wiley still calls for complete sections and appropriate statements. [3] Check the journal’s policy for reporting guidelines relevant to your study; a general checklist does not establish ethical approval or adequate reporting.
5. Inspect what will actually be submitted
- Open the final files and compare their names, versions and roles with your instruction record.
- Inspect references, tables, figure labels, captions and supplementary links in the final output.
- If anonymization is required, review the submission copy’s visible content, properties, comments and tracked changes against the journal’s instructions.
- Inspect the portal-generated preview, if provided, and verify carried-over files before finalizing.
- Record unresolved questions explicitly and retain an editable original.
This is an editorial completion workflow. It is not a certification of scientific quality or a prediction of the editorial decision. A checked package can still require clarification or further work.
Two boundaries to keep visible
Does Free Format mean that every Wiley journal accepts any submission package?
No. The cited Wiley program applies to journals that offer it. Its instructions still call for required manuscript sections, appropriate disclosures and consistent presentation. Confirm the selected journal and article type rather than inferring a policy from the publisher’s name.
Is a complete file checklist proof that the manuscript will be accepted?
No. This is a preparation aid. It checks the requested artifacts and recorded instructions, not the scientific validity of a study, editorial suitability or a future acceptance decision.
Sources and limits
The named sections of these official pages were read. Two PLOS pages are one publisher; Wiley is a separate primary policy source. These examples are not a survey of journal policies, and no acceptance or desk-rejection rate is claimed.
- PLOS ONE: submission guidelines
Style and format, manuscript length, abstract, references and individual figure files.
- PLOS ONE: revising your manuscript
Response to reviewers, marked-up and clean manuscripts, and carried-over figures/supporting files.
- Wiley: Free Format submission
Participating journals, consistent reference style, complete sections and applicable disclosures.