Follow the decision, then check who acts next.
From submission to publication: how a journal handles a manuscript
Has a reviewer actually received your manuscript? Look up the journal’s status definitions before interpreting the label. Technical checks, reviewer invitations and completed reviews are different stages.
AcademicFix Editorial Team · Sources reviewed · Bu rehberi Türkçe okuyun

On this page
Has a reviewer seen the paper?
A journal can be checking files or waiting for an invitation to be accepted.
Which review comment affects the decision?
Ask what the criticism shows and what the editor needs the author to address.
What if a table note disappears?
Trace the missing note to the approved file and check whether it changes the interpretation.
This guide is for authors following a submission and editorial teams mapping handovers. It uses Open Journal Systems (OJS) 3.5 to illustrate what a platform can do and PLOS One to show how one journal describes its stages. Status labels, decision categories and review models vary. For instance, PLOS One uses “Under review” once invitations have gone out, which leaves open whether a reviewer has accepted the invitation or returned a report. PKP: the OJS 3.5 submission stage. PLOS One: editorial and peer review process. ICMJE: submission and peer review.
Find the owner of the next action
Use this planning table with your journal’s policy. Assign a person or role to each handover, document delegated authority, and make clear when a decision is ready to communicate.
| Stage | Question to answer | Typical responsibility |
|---|---|---|
| Submission checks | Can the journal assess this package? | Editorial office or assigned editor |
| Editorial screening | Does the manuscript meet the journal’s scope and criteria for further assessment? | Authorised editor |
| Reviewer assignment | What expertise and conflict checks does this manuscript need? | Handling editor |
| Review and decision | Which issues are material to the decision? | Reviewers advise. The authorised editor decides. |
| Revision | Do the new files and response address the decision letter? | Author and handling editor |
| Copyediting and production | Does the proof preserve the approved meaning and detail? | Copyeditor, production team and author |
| After publication | What does the record need if an error or reliability concern emerges? | Editor and publishing team under the journal’s policy |
Check whether the submission is complete
Match the manuscript, author information, required declarations and supplements to the same submission. Turn the journal’s published instructions into a checklist. If a file will not open, a required declaration is missing or a table cannot be read, identify the item and explain what the author should send. Keep the technical request separate from any judgment about the research. PLOS One describes returning submissions for clarification during its initial checks. PLOS One: editorial and peer review process. Joint transparency principles.
If the journal uses text matching, inspect the passages and their sources. References, correctly quoted text and an author’s own preprint can produce matches. A small overall percentage can still contain a passage that deserves attention. Treat the report as evidence of overlap and use the journal’s integrity procedure for any concern about attribution. Crossref: interpreting a Similarity Report. Turnitin: what the similarity score measures.
Decide whether to send it for review
The editor checks the journal’s scope, article type and stated editorial criteria. Depending on the journal and article, an editor may seek external review, ask for a clarification or decline before review. The joint transparency principles call for journals to explain when they use decisions without peer review. OJS offers separate actions for sending a paper to review and recording a desk decision. Joint transparency principles. ICMJE: submission and peer review. CSE: editorial and reviewer responsibilities. PKP: the OJS 3.5 submission stage.
A desk decision letter should say which criterion determined the outcome. For a paper outside the journal’s scope, identify the mismatch without implying that a reviewer evaluated the methods. A missing document calls for a different explanation and may be correctable under the journal’s procedures.
Choose expertise and prepare review files
Choose reviewers for the claims they can assess. A paper may need one expert in the subject and another in the method. Check suggested names for relevant expertise and competing interests before sending invitations. Ask reviewers to disclose relevant relationships and reassign a review or decision when a conflict calls for recusal. CSE: editorial and reviewer responsibilities. ICMJE: disclosures and conflicts. COPE: ethical guidance for peer reviewers. PLOS One: editorial and peer review process.
Follow the journal’s stated review model. In OJS, the chosen settings control what the platform displays. If authors are meant to be anonymous to reviewers, check the actual files for names in title pages, document properties and accompanying material. The journal’s procedures determine who prepares those files and who checks them. PKP: the OJS 3.5 review stage. ICMJE: submission and peer review. CSE: editorial and reviewer responsibilities.
Read the reviews and handle concerns
A review should explain which claims the evidence supports, which methods need clarification and why a proposed change matters. Keep unpublished material confidential, check the journal’s rules before involving another person or using an AI service, and report ethics concerns to the editor through the journal’s procedure. COPE advises reviewers to report suspected irregularities to the editor and let the journal handle the inquiry. COPE: ethical guidance for peer reviewers. ICMJE: submission and peer review. CSE: editorial and reviewer responsibilities.
As an editor, distinguish a missing disclosure from evidence that a result may be unreliable. Record what is known, protect confidential information and use the journal’s procedure for the kind of concern raised. Under ICMJE guidance for medical journals, the response depends on the circumstances and may involve the relevant institution or funder. An editorial rejection and the handling of a serious allegation are separate decisions. ICMJE: misconduct, concerns and retractions. Joint transparency principles.
Explain the decision and what must change
Reviewers provide reasons and recommendations. The authorised editor weighs the reports alongside the manuscript and the journal’s criteria. A report that identifies a concrete problem with a method calls for a different response from a report that offers only general praise. State what is required for further consideration and where a reasoned response is acceptable. ICMJE: submission and peer review. Joint transparency principles. PLOS One: editorial and peer review process.
Check the revision and explain the appeal route
A request for revision leaves the decision open. Read the response beside the revised file and verify where each required change appears. If an author declines a request, assess the stated reasons. A new analysis or a materially different conclusion may warrant further review. PLOS One allows its editor to decide after reassessing the revision or to seek additional external input. OJS documents further rounds and editorial decisions as distinct options. PLOS One: editorial and peer review process. PKP: the OJS 3.5 review stage. Joint transparency principles.
An appeal concerns an editorial decision or process. A complaint can concern how the journal or its staff behaved. Use the journal’s stated route and identify the factual error, procedural issue or other grounds it accepts. The journal assesses the submission against its appeal policy. Joint transparency principles. ICMJE: submission and peer review. PLOS One: editorial and peer review process.
Compare the proof with the approved manuscript
Acceptance and the reader-facing publication are separate events. In OJS 3.5, accepted material can move into copyediting, then production after approval. PLOS One gives an example of a journal with provisional editorial acceptance followed by a separate formal acceptance before production. PKP: OJS 3.5 copyediting. PKP: OJS 3.5 production. PLOS One: editorial and peer review process.
Compare the PDF or HTML proof with the approved manuscript. Check table entries and notes, figure labels, citations and special characters. Query any change that would alter the scientific meaning and refer it to the editor. Springer Nature’s proofing guidance describes correcting typesetting and consistency errors and generally excludes changes to the findings. Springer Nature: proofing questions. PKP: OJS 3.5 production.
Verify the article page and publication version
Check the title, authors, abstract, licence and date on the article page against the approved files. Identify which version the publisher has formally made available as the Version of Record and label the accepted manuscript or proof separately. NISO’s 2026 recommendations describe these version categories and explain how to identify them in the article and metadata. NISO: Journal Article Versions, 2026. PKP: OJS 3.5 production.
For an article with a Crossref DOI, test that it resolves to a working landing page and update the deposited record when details or relevant publication status change. Follow the registration agency’s own maintenance instructions if the journal uses a different service. Crossref: maintaining your metadata.
Keep a route for correcting the record
Fictional example. A table note stating that an analysis includes only participants with complete follow-up disappears from the published PDF. The editor compares the proof, approved manuscript and live article formats, checks what the missing note changes, and asks the authors to confirm the scope. If the findings remain reliable and the omission needs correction, record what changed, when it changed and how readers of the earlier file can identify the current version.
ICMJE recommends a dated, linked correction notice and a record of earlier versions. PLOS generally explains a correction in a separate notice without replacing the original article. A correction can repair an error while the findings remain reliable. An expression of concern can alert readers while a serious issue remains unresolved. Retraction addresses cases where the published findings cannot be relied on or another ground for retraction applies. The journal should make the status visible and link a retraction notice to the original article in both directions. ICMJE: corrections and version control. ICMJE: misconduct, concerns and retractions. PLOS: correction and retraction policy. CSE: correcting the literature.
- Record the DOI or article address, version and affected passage.
- Compare the approved text with the published formats.
- Identify who assesses the effect on the interpretation and who communicates the decision.
- Check the correction or notice on the article page, in the publication files and in the relevant record.
Apply the map to one submission
Use the journal roles guide to assign authority, the anonymisation guide to inspect review files, and the response guide to record changes after review. Start with the journal submission checklist if you are preparing the files now.
ICMJE’s recommendations are written for medical journals. The joint transparency principles and CSE describe professional expectations, while PLOS One and Springer Nature describe their own procedures. PKP and Crossref document the services they operate. Check the policy that applies to your submission.