Give the task an owner and the decision a clear authority.
Who does what in an academic journal? Roles, authority and responsibilities
A board title, a reviewer recommendation and a platform permission answer different questions. Map the work before assigning access or announcing who can decide a manuscript.
AcademicFix Editorial Team · Sources reviewed: · Bu rehberi Türkçe okuyun

On this page
Can this editor finalise the decision?
A handling assignment and final decision authority can be different permissions.
Whose manuscript is being handled?
Make the independent route visible when an editor is also an author.
Which version has been approved?
Language and layout changes need a clear route for resolving changes of meaning.
A long list of names on a journal website does not tell an author who can decide their manuscript. Write down who assigns reviewers, makes the editorial decision, requests missing files and handles a published error. One person may perform several tasks, but the authority attached to each task should remain visible.
This guide is for journal teams defining or reviewing their responsibilities. It does not prescribe one staffing chart for every discipline or institution. A software role is also different from an organisational appointment: in OJS 3.5, a user may hold several roles, and role names and access to workflow stages can be configured. PKP: users, roles and permissions.
Map the task before the title
The following table is an editorial planning framework. Its authority questions are prompts for writing a journal’s own role descriptions, not statements of legal status or a compulsory hierarchy.
| Role | Main task | Authority to define in writing |
|---|---|---|
| Publisher / owner | Provide resources, infrastructure and continuity | Limits on involvement in individual manuscript decisions |
| Editor-in-chief | Oversee policy, decision arrangements and journal content | Decisions retained and decisions delegated |
| Associate / subject / section editor | Handle the assigned manuscript’s assessment | Recommendation only, or authority to finalise a decision |
| Editorial board | Perform defined editorial or policy work | Whether membership includes assignments and decision authority |
| Advisory board | Advise on direction and specialist needs | Whether any routine manuscript handling is included |
| Editorial office / managing editor | Coordinate submissions, correspondence and progress | Administrative checks versus scientific decisions |
| Reviewer | Provide an expert, reasoned assessment | Advice to the authorised editorial decision maker |
| Copyeditor | Improve expression, consistency and journal style | Approval of changes affecting scientific meaning |
| Layout / production team | Prepare readable publication files and proofs | Preserve the approved content during production |
| Technical administrator | Maintain system operation and access | Technical permissions versus editorial decision authority |
For each row, name the responsible person and, where practical, someone who can cover an absence. The same person may appear in more than one row. If the section editor also coordinates the editorial office, document both assignments and check how their access and decision responsibilities interact.
Separate publisher support from editorial authority
The publisher provides the organisational support that allows publication to continue, such as staffing, infrastructure and services. Ownership and publishing may sit with the same body or different bodies. Make that relationship understandable rather than leaving authors to infer it from a logo. Joint transparency principles: ownership and management.
The editor-in-chief oversees editorial policy and the decision process: what the journal considers, how criteria are applied, what authority is delegated and how appeals are handled. ICMJE advocates editorial freedom for medical journals, including independence from owner interference in individual submissions. CSE also recommends defining editorial autonomy in writing. These are professional frameworks, with ICMJE’s biomedical scope, rather than a universal legal rule. ICMJE: owners and editorial freedom. CSE: editor responsibilities.
A usable role description should go beyond “responsible for scientific quality”. As an editorial working aid, include handover of open submissions, absence cover, the editor’s own manuscripts and the route for an unresolved publisher–editor disagreement. Keep a record that a successor can follow.
Define what the handling editor can decide
Associate editor, section editor and subject editor are not reliable indicators of the same authority across journals. Identify the work assigned to a person and the decisions they are authorised to make. The DOAJ/OASPA toolkit distinguishes editors, managers, guest editors and boards, while recognising that staffing varies. Toolkit: roles and responsibilities.
For example, when two reports raise different concerns, the handling editor should explain which issues matter for the decision and what revision is being requested. A practical check is to read the proposed decision letter for contradictory instructions. This is an editorial exercise, not a claim that one decision method fits every journal.
OJS provides a concrete software illustration: when assigning an editor, the journal can allow that person to finalise a decision or only recommend one. Permission to edit publication details is a separate choice. Configure the system to match the journal’s written delegation; the software option does not prescribe the governance model. PKP: assigning an editor and decision authority.
Explain what board membership means
Editorial board and advisory board are labels whose meaning needs explanation. A board member may handle manuscripts, contribute to policy or advise on a particular area. An advisory appointment does not automatically confer daily handling duties, and an editorial-board appointment does not describe every permission. CSE lists active board functions as well as advisory work. CSE: editorial-board participation.
An author should be able to tell whether a listed member handles submissions, can make decisions or is consulted only on specified questions. Access to confidential files should follow the assigned task. This is a proposed role-description check, not an assumption that every board member sees every manuscript.
The joint COPE–DOAJ–OASPA–WAME principles, fifth version dated 29 October 2026, call for relevant expertise, current names and affiliations, members’ agreement to serve and periodic board review. Obtain that agreement before listing a person and update the list when their role ends. Joint principles: editorial board and advisory body.
Keep coordination and scientific assessment distinct
The editorial office may coordinate submission checks, missing-file requests, correspondence and progress tracking. The managing-editor title can cover coordination or wider editorial work, depending on the journal. State the remit rather than assuming scientific decision authority from the title. Toolkit: journal managers and managing editors.
For example, checking that an ethics statement was uploaded is an administrative task. Deciding whether that statement is adequate for the study may require the authorised editor and relevant expertise. Sending a clear missing-file list does not, by itself, constitute a scientific suitability decision. This is an illustrative division of work.
For a proposed handover record, replace the vague label “in progress” with the next action, the person responsible and the file version being used. A short record might say: “Author to supply the missing declaration; editorial office to confirm receipt; handling editor to assess it.” This is an operating suggestion, not evidence of a measured reduction in errors.
Treat a review as reasoned advice
A useful review explains the reasons for its assessment: which claim needs support, which method is unclear or where the interpretation exceeds the evidence. Keep criticism about the work rather than the author, and distinguish a necessary citation from a preference for a reviewer’s own work. ICMJE: responsibilities in peer review.
Reviewers should assess whether they can review competently, disclose relevant conflicts, protect confidential material and raise concerns with the journal. Do not treat an invitation as permission to share the manuscript with another person or an outside tool. Follow the journal’s instructions and seek permission where assistance is needed. As an editorial operating suggestion, report observed concerns through the editor rather than treating a review assignment as a mandate for a separate investigation. ICMJE: reviewer responsibilities and confidentiality. ICMJE: reviewer and editor conflicts.
A reviewer’s recommendation is advice to the decision maker. It is not an acceptance or rejection decision by itself, and a favourable report is not an acceptance guarantee. ICMJE explicitly notes that a journal need not follow either a positive or negative recommendation; the joint principles require the journal to explain its decision arrangements. ICMJE: editorial assessment. Joint principles: who makes manuscript decisions.
Protect approved meaning through production
Copyediting concerns language, consistency and publication style; production prepares the approved material in its publication formats. In PKP’s workflow, copyediting is a distinct stage following acceptance, with editors, copyeditors and authors involved in approval. PKP: copyediting and approval.
As an editorial safeguard, query an ambiguous sentence rather than silently choosing a stronger scientific meaning. At proof stage, compare table notes, symbols and figure captions with the approved text. PKP’s production documentation describes preparation of final files and metadata, with authors involved in approval of the galleys. PKP: production and final proofs.
Assign responsibility for backups, software updates, service incidents and access administration. Broad access to a publishing system is not, by itself, authority to accept a manuscript. Suggested operating checks include individual accounts, task-appropriate access, updating access when staff leave and a named route for reporting an outage. OJS permissions should be configured in line with that division of work. PKP: permission levels and workflow access.
Make combined roles and recusals visible
Different tasks need not always mean different employees. A small team may combine editing and copyediting, but that overlap should be declared in its working arrangements. For a manuscript involving an editor’s own interests, arrange independent handling. ICMJE discusses recusal and safeguards for editorial-team submissions; CSE also addresses editors submitting their own work. ICMJE: conflicts in editorial decisions. CSE: editors as authors.
Fictional planning example: in the invented Coastal Research Journal, a section editor also prepares page layouts. Those two ordinary assignments can be recorded together. When that editor submits a coauthored paper, a different authorised editor should handle the submission, with the submitting editor excluded from reviewer selection and the decision. In this example, assigning the layout work to someone else makes the separation easier to demonstrate. That additional layout handover is an AcademicFix planning suggestion, not a universal requirement or a real journal incident.
Complete a role record with five fields: the task, decision authority, information access, recusal circumstances and handover. Then walk an invented submission through the record. If the team cannot explain who acts at a step, resolve that responsibility before adding more names to the website. The record below is an editorial aid, not a certification of compliant governance.
A role record you can test
- Task: What action is expected?
- Decision authority: Who can recommend, approve or reject?
- Access: Which files and discussions are needed?
- Recusal: When does another authorised person take over?
- Handover: Which version and next action are recorded?
For the fictional editor-as-author case, write the replacement editor’s authority and the submitting editor’s excluded actions before the file enters review. Then check that the platform permissions support that arrangement.
Test the role map on one submission
For the wider launch file, use the journal-founding roadmap. Check the handover against the journal-guidelines checklist and the anonymisation guide. Then walk through the submission checklist to see which team member should act at each step.
How to use the guidance
ICMJE recommendations concern medical journals; CSE supplies a separate scientific-publishing framework, while citing related ICMJE and COPE guidance. The joint transparency principles and DOAJ/OASPA toolkit share participating organisations. They are professional recommendations, not independent experiments or one universal staffing law. PKP links document OJS 3.5 software behaviour. The table, role record and invented journal case are AcademicFix editorial aids, not measured evidence of journal quality.